DACRE HADDON SPEAKING ON THE STATE OF THE PROVINCE ADDRESS 2011

DA REPLY TO STATE OF PROVINCE ADDRESS BY PREMIER KIVIET –CADRE DEPLOYMENT:

Honourable Speaker, Honourable Premier, Members of the Executive Committee, Honourable MPL’s, Officials, media and guests – good day.Since 1994, South Africa has become a better place to live in.

Government has made enormous progress in improving the life of thousands of people in this province through accelerated housing, water and electricity provision not imagined under apartheid rule.

Madam Premier, in your speech you allude to plans to fight corruption and a broad 7 point plan process in transforming the culture of the provincial public service.

However, Premier of concern is that you do not tell us “HOW” you will implement this strategy.

Honourable Premier you also alluded in your address to the success of clean audits and the implementation of Audit and revenue enhancement policies in the province.

While this improvement is pleasing, why are we applauding ourselves with self congratulation when these are statutory requirements that should have been adhered to years ago?

Furthermore Speaker, Honourable Premier spoke about the new infrastructure in Mthatha.

This only happened because of a Presidential intervention due to chaos in water provision (or rather the lack of it) when some forward planning a few years earlier could have prevented the whole sale suffering of communities in Mthatha.

Another area of concern is the lack of public revenues.

Madam Premier, you have said nothing about how increasing public revenue will take place and why municipalities are fudging their responsibilities to collect monies owed to them.

Honourable Speaker, the main reason why there is service delivery protests and back logs is because of the government policy of “cadre deployment”.

In an article from the Mail & Guardian in the November 19-25 2010 issue titled “An independent cadre is a contradiction” by Gavin Davis, he gives a clear definition of cadre deployment and quote:

“…this principle commits every cadre to defending and implementing the will of the party leadership, wherever he or she is deployed, and even if it means acting outside the Constitution and the law. The individual cadre’s own thoughts, opinions and conscience are irrelevant. They are just loyal cadres.”

In the case of Vuyo Mlokoti vs Amathole Municipality heard in the Eastern Cape Division in 2008, Judge Pickering confirmed the illegality of cadre deployment.

A recent example of poor cadre deployment is where a cadre who was appointed Municipal Manager of Sundays River municipality

Under his watch, this municipality was driven into the ground and is subject to a section 39 intervention and there were also 11 charges of alleged mismanagement against this individual.

Then Honourable Speaker, this person was appointed to head up the Audit division (Operation Clean Audit) in the Province.

This person is now deployed as the Municipal Manager of Mbashe municipality.

This deployment and others like it boggles the mind!

Honourable Premier-as head of this province the buck stops with you!

As Captain of this Provincial ship you ultimately carry the can for the success or failures of this province.

If the ship crashes in to the rock you Honourable Premier as Captain must explain why and be accountable for the consequences..

This provincial ship has crashed into an Ice berg!

This province is dysfunctional in some areas of Education, Health, Local Government and Housing.

This Legislature itself is also shipping water – petitions get lost, accounts don’t get paid, there are water cut offs the place is generally filthy.

Honourable Speaker where the DA governs it governs well.

The success of Democratic Alliance governance in several municipalities is due to a simple philosophy-being “fit for purpose”

Honourable Speaker, allow me to highlight some examples of DA successes countrywide:

Cape Town has been declared the best municipality for service delivery in the country.

The province has received unqualified audits in all departments.

In addition, 94% of residents have access to basic sanitation and Cape Town gives 350 litres of free water a day to indigent people-the highest allocation in the country.

In Cape Town 95% of households have electricity- the highest access in the country.

Honourable Speaker, in a recent government survey the “Gauteng Planning Commission Quality of Life Survey”- Premier Nomvula Mokonyane announced that DA run Midvaal municipality was the top Gauteng municipality with the best quality of life.

Midvaal also had the highest satisfaction rating of any municipality in the province.

At the Doorkuil Housing project in Midvaal, 18000 units are being built at a cost of R8 billion.

Some 60% of these dwellings are for lower income groups. A survey found that two thirds of the low income residents from this project were either very satisfied or satisfied with the quality of their dwelling.

This was the highest housing rating in all Gauteng municipalities.

Honourable Speaker, these are just a sample of how successfully the DA governs in municipalities across the country.

Therefore Speaker the choice facing this province is stark.

If the continued policy of Cadre deployment, where loyalty to the ANC trumps capacity and commitment to do the job, then we will all face the prospect of a failed state.

Alternatively we can as the premier quoted in the conclusion of her speech have “development through unity” working together, diverse together for the common good.

The ball is in your court Madam Premier!

I thank you.