WHY are we in such a mess, I was asked this week. While colonialism and the legacy of apartheid are frequently blamed and rightly so for many of our problems; it is time one also focused on the destructive impact of the closed crony society on the state of governance in our country.

The history of civilisation is to a large extent the history of a duel between those who want a free, open society with equal opportunity for all and those who want a closed society with special status for a select few, with opportunities only available through patronage.

It is a shame that academics, business, church and other leaders have not homed in on this idea as the root cause of many of our social ills today. Many avoid the subject through fear of being seen to appear politically incorrect.

Let’s stop pussyfooting around and call a spade a spade. Apartheid only lasted as long as it did because people who knew better lacked the courage to speak out and stand up. As someone who vigorously opposed apartheid it saddens me to see history repeating itself.

The three legs of the closed crony society are cadre deployment, looting of state resources and the abuse of state institutions for political purposes, of which the undermining of the criminal justice system is the most frightening.

Unless we can cut off these legs, we are firmly on the road to a failed state.

In the closed crony society your ability to get ahead in life does not depend on what you know or your ability to perform, but rather on who you know. You look after your friends, family and faction – the three F’s and they in turn keep you in a position of authority and power – a closed circle feeding each other.

This culture has taken root where the ANC governs. The workings of government are crippled, if not brought to a standstill in some cases, as factions vie for ascendency. The Nelson Mandela Metro recently had to abort a council meeting because too few councillors pitched up as a result of the clash between the Mayor and the ANC regional executive. Service delivery suffers as they fight for control. The real tragedy is that there is no public outrage. It’s just accepted as the norm.

A further consequence of the closed crony society can be found in the example of the non-delivery of textbooks in Limpopo, half way into the school year. Has anybody been fired? Why has no politician resigned? What of the disastrous impact on the pupils?

When people obtain positions or contracts for the wrong reasons, it becomes impossible to fire them for the right reasons. Factionalism and cadre deployment trump accountability.

The looting of state resources is not always as crude as blatant theft or corruption dosed with maladministration. It can be a lot more sophisticated than that. Tenders are badly advertised, specifications drawn in such a way to suit a particular company or they are awarded at vastly inflated prices and subcontracted via middlemen to the people who actually do the work.

Resources that should be there for the upliftment of the poor are stolen.

When the National prosecuting authority has disregarded an order of the Supreme Court of Appeal by failing to provide the DA with the record of decision relating to the dropping of corruption charges against President Jacob Zuma, there is cause for alarm. Four months ago they were given 14 days to do so.

There is of course an alternative and that is the open opportunity society for all that is underpinned by the concepts of reconciliation, delivery, redress and diversity.

It is working so well in places where the Democratic Alliance governs that Zwelinzima Vavi once again warned this week that the DA could become the government in 2019.

Our future can be different but each of us must reach deep within ourselves and ask how one can be a better agent for change so history does not repeat itself. Just this week we celebrated Nelson Mandela Day and reminded ourselves of the values of selfless service, sacrifice, accountability and above all the dream of the rainbow nation. These are values that won Mandela world recognition. They are becoming foreign to the ANC of today.


  1. JFB says:

    I am surprised that people are surprised that things aren’t going better in our country. Substitute one human for another, and expect success, based on what? Based on a skin colour? Based on a better system, where humans are still involved?

    Also, who determined that church leaders should stand up with state leaders and others, to fight their demons for them? Interesting take, since so many people insist that church and state should be kept separate. I for one could easily agree with that.

    Let me say, however, that I am a huge fan of Helen Zille and her party. I am jealous of Western Cape people. Not only do they have the Stormers, they also have the DA 😉

  2. Margaret Gould says:

    Seventeen years down the road, it is a cop out to blame apartheid. We had the opportunity to shine, and be a truly free democratic society, and a shining example to the world – the ANC has blown it, along with the apathy of our society. It is in the interest of the ANC to keep the masses improvised and at the mercy of hand-outs from the government and it is in the ANC’s best interest to keep them uneducated: An educated person votes with their head, an uneducated person votes with their heart: As long as it is seen to be providing houses and hand-outs, the uneducated will vote for the ANC.

    Farm murders, affirmative action and BBBEE is just another form of apartheid that isolates and excludes a section of our society. South Africans will only be truly free once they remove their hatred and anger (although I can understand it), and start working for a better society for all South Africans. This requires enormous courage: To forgive! It also requires the courage to vote the ANC out of power and hopefully eliminate the abuses this government has allowed into our society. It is time that all South Africans threw off their blanket of apathy, and stand up against the crimes of the ANC. Heaven help us if Zuma is voted into power again: Zimbabwe here we come!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.