The DA exposed poor conditions at the Madwaleni Hospital during a recent visit.

The DA will be writing to the Eastern Cape Human Rights Commission to request that the HRC broadens its consideration of an investigation to include all health issues in the Eastern Cape, including equipment shortages, staffing shortages and human resource issues, a lack of medical supplies and poor basic infrastructure.

A visit by myself and DA deputy Shadow Minister of Health, Denise Robinson, to the Madwaleni Hospital revealed issues that are likely to have a critical impact on the level of service that can be provided to patients.

Examples of the staffing shortages and human resource issues encountered include:

  • There is one doctor and two clinical associates to service a 180 bed hospital as well as the out-patients department.
  • There is no human resources manager at the hospital and many staff have not received salaries.
  • No surgeon is available so no surgery can take place including caesarean sections, despite the website proclaiming that there are 24 hours Caesarean section facilities available.

This has meant that pregnant mothers and patients with fractures and other emergency conditions are forced to depend on an unreliable ambulance service and undergo an hour and a half journey on pothole filled roads to Mthatha for medical treatment at the Nelson Mandela Academic Hospital.

The serious lack of medical supplies is evidenced by the unavailability of gloves and disinfectant soaps, an insufficient number of oxygen tanks to supply all the wards and the limited availability of appropriate sizes of syringes and bandages.

Poor basic infrastructure that patients and hospital staff are exposed to include:

  • The majority of hospital beds are broken or are in poor repair.
  • There are no facilities available for mothers with sick children to sleep over so they are forced to sleep on the floor.
  • Nurses are living in one room old garages without any running water, ablution facilities or electricity points.
  • Electricity and running water is temperamental.

This exposure of the poor hospital conditions comes after DA site visits to state hospitals in the Eastern Cape in July revealed that chronic hospital equipment shortages were putting the lives of patients at serious risk. The visit to Madwaleni Hospital reflected that essential equipment shortages are still prevalent. The X-Ray Department has been closed down as no X-Ray machine has been provided despite applying for one every year since 2006.

We wrote to the Human Rights Commission (HRC) to request an urgent investigation into the impact of hospital equipment shortages on the rights of patients to have access to health care.

The HRC acknowledged receipt of the complaint on 06 August and referred the complaint to the Eastern Cape HRC Office on 28 September. We have followed up on the status on the matter and are awaiting reply.

The right to health services is protected by the Constitution and the Human Rights Commission has a mandate to promote the protection, development and attainment of human rights.  They must investigate the health care crisis in Eastern Cape public hospitals and the impact it has on patients and staff.

An investigation into this issue is essential if we are to attain an accessible, caring and high quality health care system for all South Africans – our people have waited long enough.

The Human Rights Commission must include evidence of chronic medical staffing shortages and human resource issues, a lack of medical supplies and poor basic infrastructure in its investigation into health service delivery in the Eastern Cape.

  1. Wankie Moerane says:

    DA Bisho, am requesting your office to look into Health issues,hospitals in the then Transkei Tsolo,Maclear,Mt Fletcher,
    Look into Elundini municipality Ward 6/9 areas Upper Sinxaku or Emambulwini
    A)access to road
    b) health issues there are no clinics whatsoever
    C) access to school transport
    D) access to SABC /tv
    E) access to RDP
    F)access to sanitation /toilets
    G)access to technology -Internet for schools and community at large
    H) education programmes for preprimary/crèche/nursery

  2. Andre Naude says:

    I spent 40 years with Adcock Ingram Critical Care- under various churches hospitals in Transkei & Ciskei were well run- the Transkei hospital;s were taken over in the early 1970’s- still reasonably run- never short of supplies ortequipment- Ciskei took over mission hospital in the early 1980’s also well run, albeit with foreign Dr’s- 1994 saw all former CPA, Ciskei and Transkei hospitals being poorly managed by East Cape health- I had on numerous occasions visited Bisho in order to obtain payment for outstanding accounts- Frere Hoispital was on a continuos supply problem , as their accounts were outstanding for 120 days plus- closure of old Ciskei Medical Store in EL was a further blowo health care, as supplies had to be delivered out of PE or Mthatha.
    What a pity to see these hospitals, that had given such good service to their communitiesd going straight down the drain- The ANC has destroyed what has been built up since 1652- blame always placed upon apartheid- whose policy I disagreed with, but must say they delivered a fantastic service